The Return of the King by J.R.R Tolkien (Harper Collins 1991) pp. 819-820
When I first read The Lord of the Rings back in the late 1960s only a handful of people on the planet had ever heard of Oromë the Great and I was most certainly not one of those! Like most Tolkien fans of that time I had to wait for the publication of The Silmarillion in the 1970s to meet the God of War for the very first time. But, just as one of my correspondents in the Comments on this blog have written, the charge of the Rohirrim is one of the great scenes, both in Tolkien’s masterpiece and in Peter Jackson’s movies as well. It is one of Tolkien’s eucatastrophes when our hearts are moved, sometimes to tears, at the sudden unlooked for turn from darkness to light that this moment in the story represents. And sometimes when I need to find courage in myself, I seek out the clip from the movie of the moment when the action suddenly turns from the despair at the gates of Minas Tirith to the arrival of the Rohirrim on the ridge above the battle.
But what of Oromë the Great? Tolkien writes of how Théoden seizes a great horn from his banner-bearer and blows “such a blast upon it” that it bursts asunder. Oromë is a name that denotes the blowing of a horn, the sound of the trumpet that announces the judgement and the casting down of darkness. The Silmarillion tells us that Morgoth so feared Oromë that he cast up the Misty Mountains in order to prevent Oromë from riding against him.
So, after Théoden calls the Rohirrim to battle as I wrote about in the last piece in this blog, we read that he leads his men in a mighty charge, as he rides out in front of every one of them, and that he “could not be overtaken.”
“Fey he seemed, or the battle-fury of his fathers ran like new fire in his veins, and he was borne up on Snowmane like a god of old, even as Oromë the Great in the battle of the Valar when the world was young. His golden shield was uncovered, and lo! it shone like an image of the Sun, and the grass flamed into green above the white feet of his steed. For morning came, morning and a wind from the sea; and darkness was removed, and the hosts of Mordor wailed, and terror took them, and they fled and died.”
There is little doubt that at this moment something greater than himself takes hold of Théoden. Homer would have no doubt in saying that it is a god that has suddenly come to the battlefield. Carl Jung would speak in terms of an archetype. Who is right? Even Tolkien seems ambiguous at this point as he uses words such as “like a god of old” or “even as Oromë the Great”. The Lord of the Rings is a story told at the boundary between myth and history and at this moment the language moves away from history towards myth and it becomes wonderful as it does so even as it becomes terrifying. But as we look at the words that I have just quoted here, we see that Tolkien is not able simply to give himself over to myth; he speaks in terms of like or even, evoking the mythic while not giving himself over to it.
Dome Karukoski’s biopic of Tolkien’s early life released in 2019 has a moment in it that I think addresses the ambiguity that I am trying to address here very well. Tolkien was present at the terrible Battle of the Somme in 1916 when 32,000 British soldiers were killed on the first day and many more wounded. Karukoski weaves scenes from this battle throughout the movie and there is one in which Tolkien suddenly sees a medieval knight in full armour riding by and for just a moment the atmosphere changes from the brutal carnage of modern mechanised warfare to one that possesses majesty and beauty. We are left to wonder whether Tolkien is hallucinating at that moment but scholars have become clear that the legendarium that he began to create in the trenches on the Western Front and in the years that followed was an effort to process the horror that he experienced.
I will write more about this in my next piece on this blog but here I want to end by noting that although the mighty charge of the Rohirrim turns the tide of the battle of the Pelennor Fields it is not decisive. Indeed the very next paragraph in Tolkien’s telling of the story makes that clear as it turns from the great charge to the Morgul Lord whose “arm was long” even though the battle had for a moment turned against him. In the end the battle was won by many things, not least the courage of a frightened hobbit and a young woman who for a little while had given up on life. The great ride of the Rohirrim is a glorious thing but it is still just one thing among many.
Thank you for another uplifting essay full of insights.
To add my own (mundane) insight, I actually have a few “war” horns of my own, and I practice “winding” then sometimes. Every once in a while I manage to produce a respectable sound ! You would truly have to be channeling Divine power to blow such a blast that a horn would burst asunder! ❤️🔥
Like you, this scene put me in mind of the first day of the Battle of the Somme. The Canadians were among the first to be caught up in it. Andrew Roberts’s account brings out the mix of different regiments from Britain’s then territories around the world, a response that invites gratitude still, at this recent time of Remembrance. That Tolkien was there adds authenticity to his descriptions of bravery and sacrifice. I agree that the film’s enactment of the charge is one of the best in that adaptation, though in general I have mixed views about the films. In the midst of the account, it’s good to be reminded of the heroism of Eowyn and Merry.