“You Must Choose Between Orders and The Life of Faramir.” Pippin Acts Against Orders and For What is Right and Good.

The Return of the King by J.R.R Tolkien (Harper Collins 1991) pp. 807-809

After he dismisses Pippin from his service, Denethor gives orders for his funeral and for the funeral of Faramir. We are given a sombre and dignified description of a procession to Rath Dinen, the street of the dead, the resting place of the Stewards of Gondor.

But no-one has died.

The procession does not take place after death but before it. What Denethor has done is to order a ritual suicide. This is what he means by using the word, heathen. Tolkien would have known the description of a ship burial of a Viking lord in which the observer described the ritual murder of slaves who were then placed around the chieftain on the ship before it was set alight. The intention was that he should not make his journey into the afterlife alone and unattended.

But it is not slaves or servants that are to be ritually murdered in Rath Dinen but Denethor’s own son. And so Pippin runs from his lord in search of aid and thus finds Beregond. Pippin and Beregond have become friends in a very short time, the kind of friendship that can be forged in time of war. We saw this with Faramir and Frodo, perhaps most profoundly with Frodo and Sam; and now we see it with Pippin and Beregond. And perhaps what has bound them most closely together is their shared love for Faramir and it is this bond that now leads both of them to act in a way that is unthinkable for almost everyone else in Gondor. They choose deliberately to disobey an order that has been given by their lord.

“But the Lord of the City, Beregond, has fallen before his city is taken. He is fey and dangerous.”

And Pippin speaks of the orders that Denethor has given for his own suicide and the murder of his son, and bids Beregond to do what he can to prevent this crime from taking place. And when Beregond still speaks of orders that he must obey, Pippin declares:

“Well, you must choose between orders and the life of Faramir,” said Pippin. “And as for orders, I think you have a madman to deal with, not a lord.”

Those who have served in the military know how serious a matter it is to deliberately disobey an order, especially an order that has come from the very top, but in the world that Tolkien brings us into there is an added dimension of seriousness. For in the northern world to disobey your lord was to declare yourself to be a non-person.

In the classic Old English poem, The Wanderer, we are told of the sorrows of a man who has no lord, and so is doomed to wander from land to land in search of one who might “show me recognition in his mead-hall.” What Pippin calls upon Beregond to do is to become an exile, to become homeless by choice. And indeed, when later in the story Beregond has to stand before Aragorn and answer for what he has done, he is indeed sent into exile, never to return to Minas Tirith. The judgement of the king will indeed be tempered by a remarkable act of mercy but at no point does Aragorn seek to minimise the gravity of Beregond’s deed, nor does Beregond expect him to do so. The law has been broken and blood has been shed.

All of this takes place in a moment, as Pippin runs down to the heart of the battle in search of Gandalf, and Beregond runs up to the Street of the Dead in order to defend Faramir, if he can. Beregond’s choice is not made as a conclusion to an ethics seminar; and if it had, how much weight could we give to such a choice? Beregond’s decision to put his own body between Denethor’s servants and the lord that he loves and for whom he would happily die is a decision that can only be made when it is literally a decision made between life and death. And before such a choice those of us who read what Beregond does in the pages of Tolkien’s great story cannot sit in judgement either upon him or the men that he will kill. We must sit in silence, recognising as we do so the awfulness of what is about to take place.

And as we do so we recognise that awe is what we are called to. Awe in the face of the horror and beauty of life, and the moment at which life comes to its end, either in peace or in terror.

10 thoughts on ““You Must Choose Between Orders and The Life of Faramir.” Pippin Acts Against Orders and For What is Right and Good.”

  1. Dear Stephen, For me, today’s excerpt and your reflections on it complete last week’s passage and your thoughts about the true captain. He is the embodiment of the good, the true, and the beautiful, so when Pippin and Beregond fight for Faramir’s life, they are fighting to ensure that goodness, truth, and beauty will exist still when the war is over, thinking of the future (whether they were conscious of doing so or not) as Dietrich Bonhoeffer did. Jesus Christ put the most succinct point on this when he said “I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life”. He is God incarnate, so when we follow the person Jesus, we hold to all he is, all he teaches, and thus at least try to put these eternal principles into practice in day-to-day life and hope for forgiveness when we fail (as in Beregond’s experience). Thanks so much for delving into this idea of the true captain and doing what’s right even when the price you pay may be very high. Blessings, Kate P.S.: I never before made the connection between ancient Norse burial rituals and Denethor’s suicide/attempted murder of Faramir. Learned something new!

    • Dear Kate, the thought that comes to mind as I think about these thoughts, is of Gandalf’s words to Faramir after the debate with Denethor. “You will be needed here, for other things than war.” You are absolutely right to link these things together, and I greatly appreciate your drawing my attention to this.
      I drew upon Bonhoeffer’s thought when writing this piece. He was a part of the failed conspiracy in 1944 to assassinate Hitler and overthrow the Nazi regime. He never sought to justify the attempted assassination as “just”. He knew it could not be justified as a righteous act. He argued that sin can never be justified, that God only justifies sinners. I think this is a very important distinction. I can never argue that such an action was “necessary” if it is a breaking of the moral law.

      • a couple different places in the essay, really:

        For one, the allusion to The Wanderer, with the poignant thought of being leaderless. ( I feel this keenly in the US now)

        Also the words about feeling awe when confronted by the beauty and horror or terror of life.

        One of my favorite poems is called “A Crystal Moment” by Robert Tristram Coffin. In it the poet describes seeing a deer chased by dogs, and he sees both the deer and the dogs are beautiful and intense and ardent. He says: “so they passed, a pageant such/ as only gods could witness much: life and death upon one tether,/ running beautiful together” .

      • Thank you so much for sharing these thoughts, Barbara. I was especially touched by the words, “life and death upon one tether, / running beautiful together.” I think they evoke the tragic scene when Beregond stands guard against his comrades in defence of Faramir so powerfully.

  2. As you have written before, Faramir would be needed after the War. Pippin and Beregond chose to do the right thing, rather than following orders, as indeed military personal must choose when given orders contrary to their consciences. The price was the lives of Denethor’s servants and Beregond’s subsequent exile. Maybe choice, is not the right word. Necessity is perhaps better, and of course the whole story is woven with decisions made with this in mind.
    I often wonder how Faramir would have felt visiting Minas Tirith in the times after the War but having to leave the Captain of his Guard in Ithilien, the knight who saved his life. And without Faramir, would Éowyn have found the will to live?
    I have always had a hope, possibly a fool’s hope, that the King would pardon Beregond at some point, so that he could return home before his life ended.
    Chris

    • Thank you so much for leaving this comment, Chris. I appreciate it very much. Thank you for the reminder that soldiers are not required to obey orders that go against the law or their consciences. I wonder if this goes back to the defence often made at the Nuremburg trials by those who had participated in the Holocaust that “they were only obeying orders”. I also hope that Beregond’s exile would eventually end, although in any visit to Minas Tirith he would have to endure meetings with the families of the soldiers he killed who were obeying Denethor’s orders.

  3. I want to highlight Pippin’s foresight in knowing when to go against orders and go against Denethor in summoning Gandalf to stop him from killing Faramir. PIppin is a hobbit that grew so much from when he first set out from the Shire. Without PIppin, so much would be changed in the course of the Quest.

    “And as we do so we recognise that awe is what we are called to. Awe in the face of the horror and beauty of life, and the moment at which life comes to its end, either in peace or in terror.” Lovely writing

    • Many thanks for your thoughts here. I agree that Pippin has grown so much in his journey from the Shire, and that knowing when to disobey orders is a profound sign of the maturity that he has achieved. I think we can safely say that without Pippin the work of the Fellowship would have been in vain, maybe even the destruction of the Ring itself.

Leave a Reply