It is with the greatest reluctance that I must leave Faramir today. Frodo and Sam only had the briefest of stays with him and for much of that time were uncertain about the true nature of the man they had just met. Over this summer I have had the pleasure of returning once again to their encounter and to spend some months both enjoying it and reflecting upon it.
Faramir now bids farewell to his guests, allowing the Ring to depart with them, not clinging to the last opportunity to achieve certain victory for Gondor, choosing rather to risk defeat, enslavement and darkness than a victory that would in reality be an even greater darkness than the triumph of Sauron. In this refusal to cling Faramir chooses to empty himself and as they part so Frodo speaks:
“Most gracious host… it was said to me by Elrond Halfelven that I should find friendship upon the way, secret and unlooked for. Certainly I looked for no such friendship as you have shown. To have found it turns evil to great good.”
Surely as Frodo speaks he is thinking of the evil of Boromir’s attempt to seize the Ring and to do what Faramir refused to do. At this moment of the story Frodo knows nothing of Boromir’s final triumph over the power of evil at work in his soul and can see only the uncontrolled lust disfiguring that once fair face. The memory of that face has stayed with him from that moment until now and it has darkened Frodo’s heart. Not only has he not looked for such friendship as Faramir has shown him but he has feared untruth, hidden intent and betrayal. Such fear has a way of gaining a creeping hold even upon the most noble of hearts and so in Frodo’s thanks he speak of the evil that such a creeping hold will bring about. It is his own heart that has been set free from that evil by Faramir’s friendship.
And what of the future? Neither Frodo nor Faramir can look ahead to see what the future might bring. Faramir has already said that he cannot speak to Frodo with “soft words”.
“I do not hope to see you again on any other day under this Sun.”
Neither Frodo nor Faramir expects to escape the evil of the final triumph of the Dark Lord any more any more than Saruman expects it and so becomes an ally of Sauron hoping either to share in his triumph or to gain the Ring for himself or to even to make one when his Ring lore is complete. Faramir and Frodo have no more expectation of victory than Saruman does and yet they refuse to follow his way, the way of despair.
Surely this is the insight that Dante had when he spoke of the words written over the gateway into Hell, “Abandon all hope all you that enter here!” at the beginning of his Divine Comedy? There is a profound difference between the loss of hope for one’s own personal survival and even the triumph of one’s cause and the loss of hope that leads to either a passive or active embracing of evil. The latter is surely the despair of Hell, the despair of Sauron or of Saruman. The former believes that in the rejection of despair even the greatest of evil will be turned to good in a manner that as yet is entirely unforeseen. In the friendship that Faramir offers to Frodo and that Frodo at last is able to receive they both say their “Yes” to this belief.
To have found such friendship must turn even the greatest evil to great good.
5 thoughts on “To Have Found Such Friendship Turns Evil to Great Good”
I bet you are as sad as Frodo to be leaving Faramir.
However, I can’t wait until you get to Shelob’s Lair and all the love in that scene. 🙂
I don’t think I can be as sad as Frodo. I don’t have that hollow feeling in my heart at the thought of having to continue a journey that seems to have no hope. And Shelob’s Lair is just terrifying! Still I agree with you about the love and hope that when we get there I can write about that as best as I can.
Bwa! This gave me chills… the transcendent, self-abandoning hope that cannot be crushed or killed. There are few things more powerful in all creation. Perhaps nothing more powerful, save transcendent Love.
What a powerful and moving post. After a hiatus I’ve finally had the chance to catch up with your excellent blog. These posts on Frodo’s meeting with Faramir have been wonderful to read.
Thank you for reading them. As I have said elsewhere they have meant a lot to me. I would want Faramir to be my captain. He is a man of courage, both physical and moral and he is a man of insight. Where are the leaders like that?